Comparing Toner Ingredients for Pore Tightening and Irritation
Question
Could you please advise on which of the following two toners is more likely to be effective for pore tightening and which is less likely to cause irritation, based on their ingredient lists?
Toner 1 has the following ingredients listed prominently (towards the beginning):
- Witch Hazel Extract
- Lemon Grass Extract
- Horsetail Extract
- Horse Chestnut Seed Extract
It also contains the following ingredients listed towards the middle to end:
- DMAE
- Thioctic (Alpha Lipoic) Acid
- Vitamin C-Ester
Toner 2 has the following ingredients listed prominently (towards the beginning):
- aloe barbadensis leaf
- (un-distilled certified organic witch hazel) extract
- rosa centifolia (rose) flower water
- citric acid
- citrus grandis (grapefruit)
It also contains the following ingredient listed towards the end:
- vit E
Based on these formulations, which toner is more likely to effectively help with pore tightening, and which one is less likely to cause irritation?
Answer
Based on the ingredients you provided and the staff's assessment:
Pore Tightening
Toner 1 appears to be more suitable for pore tightening. It contains key ingredients like Witch Hazel Extract and DMAE listed early on. Witch Hazel is known for its astringent properties, which can help temporarily tighten pores. DMAE is often used for its skin-firming effects.
Irritation Potential
Toner 1 has a slightly higher potential for irritation compared to Toner 2, according to the staff. However, they noted that the overall chance of irritation is still low. Toner 2 includes soothing ingredients such as Aloe Barbadensis Leaf and Rosa Centifolia (Rose) Flower Water, which may help to reduce the likelihood of irritation.
In summary, if your main concern is pore tightening, Toner 1 seems more promising due to its active ingredients. If you have sensitive skin, be mindful of the potential for irritation with Toner 1, although it is considered low.
