Comparison and Usage of PE-1 Aqua and Pentylene Glycol as Penetration Enhancers
Question
Could you please clarify the correct usage of PE-1 Aqua as a penetration enhancer?
Specifically:
- Can Pentylene Glycol directly replace PE-1 Aqua?
- What is the optimal usage concentration range for PE-1 Aqua?
- How does PE-1 Aqua interact with other ingredients, such as:
- Propylene Glycol
- Pentylene Glycol
- Butylene Glycol
- Ethoxydiglycol
- Liposomes (especially those from Lecithin)
- Oil-soluble active ingredients
- Essential Oils
- Chemical sunscreens
Are there any ingredients or conditions that should be avoided when using PE-1 Aqua to ensure its effectiveness?
Answer
No, pentylene glycol cannot directly replace PE-1 Aqua, and their efficacies are not the same.
- PE-1 Aqua is highly effective for carrying water-soluble ingredients, particularly at a concentration of 1-4%. It is generally not suitable for oil-soluble ingredients and may even reduce their effectiveness.
- Pentylene Glycol can help carry both water and oil-soluble ingredients, but its effectiveness for water-soluble ingredients is not as high as PE-1 Aqua. It is the appropriate choice for formulas containing only oil-soluble ingredients.
For formulas containing only water-soluble ingredients, the best approach for penetration enhancement is often a combination of PE-1 Aqua and pentylene glycol, followed by using PE-1 Aqua alone, and then pentylene glycol alone.
For formulas containing only oil-soluble ingredients, pentylene glycol is the recommended option.
It's important to note that combining penetration enhancers can be complex, and the optimal ratios and combinations depend on the specific formula. Certain ingredients, such as Essential Oils, chemical sunscreens, and Ethoxydiglycol (except for self-tanning agents), should generally be avoided in formulas using PE-1 Aqua as they can reduce its effectiveness or carry unwanted substances into the skin.
Related Products Mentioned
