Black Colorants for Charcoal Soap: Charcoal vs. Mica for Blackness and Gloss
Question
When making charcoal soap, is using Activated Carbon (charcoal) alone sufficient to achieve a black color, or is it necessary to add black mica (such as Bright Black Mica, Silver Black Mica, or Black Mica ดำ เข้ม)? What is the difference in the color/finish provided by Activated Carbon compared to black mica, and can mica's shimmer/gloss effect be achieved when combined with the intense black color of charcoal?
Answer
Based on your question and the replies you've received, here's a breakdown regarding black colorants for your charcoal soap:
- Activated Carbon (Charcoal): This ingredient will provide a deep, matte black color to your soap. If your main goal is just a black color, Activated Carbon is sufficient and generally more cost-effective than mica.
- Black Mica / Silver Black Mica: Mica powders add shimmer, pearl effect, or gloss. If you want your soap to be black and glossy or shimmery, you would need to add black mica. However, as noted in the replies, the intense black color of Activated Carbon can potentially mask the shimmer effect of the mica, making the gloss less noticeable unless used in high concentrations or specific techniques.
In summary:
- If you only need a black (matte) color, Activated Carbon is enough.
- If you want a black color with a noticeable shimmer/gloss, you will need to add black mica, but be aware that the charcoal might reduce the visibility of the shimmer. You may need to experiment to achieve the desired effect.
The black mica options you listed (Bright Black Mica, Silver Black Mica, Black Mica ดำ เข้ม) are generally suitable for soap, but their specific effect might vary slightly. The 'Dark Black Mica' might provide a more intense black base from the mica itself.
Consider your desired final look. If gloss is essential, you will need mica, but manage your expectations regarding the shimmer visibility when combined with charcoal.
Related Products Mentioned
