Choosing a Thickener for Makeup Remover Gel

When formulating a makeup remover gel, both Pro Polymer and Xanthan Gum can be used as thickeners. However, considering the specific function of a makeup remover (to cleanse and be rinsed off, not to deliver ingredients into the skin), and aiming for a pleasant texture, there are some points to consider.

• Pro Polymer: This gel maker creates a gel structure and can be used in water-based formulas. While it can thicken, its characteristics, such as potentially creating a creamy pudding texture at high concentrations or an initial sticky feeling, might not be ideal for a makeup remover. As you noted, it can also have properties related to delivering substances, which is not necessary for a product designed to be washed off.

• Xanthan Gum: This is a natural thickener that creates a clear gel texture. The specific type (clear gel, smooth texture) is suitable for creating gels, serums, creams, or lotions. It can be used to achieve the desired viscosity in a makeup remover gel.

• SugarThick: Based on the staff's recommendation and the product description, SugarThick is often a preferred choice for cleansing formulations like makeup removers, liquid soaps, and shampoos. It is specifically designed to thicken formulas containing detergents/surfactants, which are typically present in makeup removers to help dissolve makeup. SugarThick provides a clear gel texture, gives a good skin-feel without being greasy, and can help reduce irritation from harsh detergents. It is also easy to incorporate into formulas.

Recommendation:

While both Pro Polymer and Xanthan Gum can technically thicken a makeup remover gel, SugarThick is generally recommended for this type of formulation. Its compatibility with detergents, ability to improve texture, and potential to reduce irritation make it highly suitable for a makeup remover gel that contains cleansing agents. Xanthan Gum is also a viable option, offering a clear gel texture, but SugarThick may provide a superior feel and performance in a detergent-based system.