Calcium Pantothenate vs. Panthenol (Vitamin B5) ExtraLite

Based on the product information:

• Calcium Pantothenate is a white to light yellow powder. At a 3% concentration, it is not typically described as having a strong odor or causing stickiness. It is noted as being easily absorbed.

• Panthenol (Vitamin B5) ExtraLite is a clear liquid. While it is specifically designed to be non-sticky and absorb easily, even at higher concentrations, it is explicitly mentioned as having a distinct smell that may require masking with fragrance.

Comparison:

• Smell: Calcium Pantothenate is unlikely to have the strong odor you experienced with Panthenol ExtraLite.
• Texture: Both are designed for good absorption and minimal stickiness. Panthenol ExtraLite is specifically highlighted as non-sticky even at higher uses, while Calcium Pantothenate at its recommended maximum of 3% is also not expected to be sticky.
• Absorption/Quality: Both are presented as forms of Vitamin B5 with enhanced absorption compared to standard Panthenol, offering benefits like moisturizing, reducing redness, and aiding skin repair. Calcium Pantothenate is a salt form, and Panthenol ExtraLite is an ethyl ether form, each with properties aimed at improving performance.

Conclusion:

If the strong smell of Panthenol (Vitamin B5) ExtraLite is your primary concern, Calcium Pantothenate appears to be a suitable alternative. At the recommended usage rate of up to 3%, it should provide the benefits of Vitamin B5 without the strong odor or significant stickiness, based on the product description. You can try replacing Panthenol ExtraLite with Calcium Pantothenate at a similar concentration (up to 3%) to see if it meets your needs regarding smell and texture while providing comparable skin benefits.