Comparison and Usage of Poloxamer 184/407 and MakeUp-Wash in Cleansing Water

Hello,

Thank you for your questions regarding Poloxamer 184, Poloxamer 407, and their use in cleansing water formulations compared to MakeUp-Wash (PEG-6 Caprylic/Capric Glycerides).

Based on your questions and the staff's reply:

1. Difference between Poloxamer 184 and Poloxamer 407: Poloxamer 184 and Poloxamer 407 are different types of poloxamers. While both are non-ionic surfactants, their molecular weights and structures differ, leading to different properties. For Cleansing Water formulations, Poloxamer 184 is specifically recommended.
2. Comparison with MakeUp-Wash (PEG-6 Caprylic/Capric Glycerides): Both Poloxamers (like Poloxamer 184) and PEG-6 Caprylic/Capric Glycerides function as surfactants and are commonly used in micellar water formulations to lift and remove makeup and impurities. They work by forming micelles that encapsulate oil and dirt. However, as the staff mentioned, their performance, skin feel, and potential for irritation can differ. Comparative testing in your specific formula is needed to determine which is best for your desired outcome, as manufacturers often do not provide direct comparison data between different ingredients.
3. Using Poloxamer 184/407 with your existing formula: The staff recommends using only one primary surfactant system rather than combining multiple types like Poloxamer 184 with Coco Wash and MakeUp-Wash. If you choose to use Poloxamer 184, a recommended starting point is 3%. You would likely need to adjust or remove the other primary surfactants (Coco Wash, MakeUp-Wash) to formulate effectively with Poloxamer 184. Using Poloxamer 184 is known for its mildness, which can help reduce eye irritation.
4. Information on the website: We understand you'd like more detailed information. Ingredient data sheets from manufacturers sometimes lack direct comparative studies between different ingredients (like Poloxamer 184 vs. PEG-6 Caprylic/Capric Glycerides regarding efficacy or irritation), which limits the information we can provide on the website. Formulation often requires experimental testing to determine the best combination and concentration for specific goals. We will continue to add information as it becomes available.

We hope this clarifies your questions!