Emulsifiers for Adding Natural Oils to Liquid Soap

Regarding your question about adding natural oils to a liquid soap formula and finding a suitable emulsifier, based on the previous discussion, there are several options to consider since ClearClean is not currently available.

Here's a summary of the alternatives discussed and their suitability:

• Flora Solve™ Clear: This is suggested as a good option for incorporating oils, particularly fragrances and essential oils, into water-based formulas. It can also work for natural oils. It is typically used at 2-5 times the amount of the oil. It helps create a clear, stable emulsion.
• Pro Polymer™: This can be used to emulsify oils (e.g., 5% oil with 0.5% Pro Polymer™). However, as noted in the discussion and product description, it will significantly thicken the formula, potentially turning it into a gel rather than a liquid soap, and will make the formula cloudy instead of clear. It can also trap air bubbles.
• Polysorbate 20 (Tween 20): This is suitable for very low amounts of oil, around 1-2%. For higher oil percentages, you would need a large amount of Polysorbate 20, which may not be ideal.
• Coco Wash™ and MakeUp-Wash™: These are presented as easier alternatives to emulsifying natural oils directly. They are modified oils that are already water-soluble and provide moisturizing properties while cleansing. Using these might eliminate the need for a separate emulsifier for the natural oil, as they themselves contribute a conditioning oil-like component that is compatible with water.

Given that ClearClean is unavailable, and considering the ease of use and effectiveness for moderate oil levels without excessive thickening or cloudiness (compared to Pro Polymer™ or large amounts of Polysorbate 20), Flora Solve™ Clear appears to be a suitable emulsifier for adding natural oils to your liquid soap base. Alternatively, using Coco Wash™ or MakeUp-Wash™ directly in your formula is the simplest approach if you want the moisturizing benefits of an oil-like ingredient that is already water-compatible.

Remember the advice from the discussion: if skin dryness is the primary concern, first try reducing the concentration of the main cleansing surfactant (like AminoWash™) before adding oils or conditioning agents.