Feedback on Powder Cleanser Formulas

Thank you for sharing your proposed powder cleanser formulas and questions. Here is a summary of the feedback based on the staff's response:

Proposed Formula 1

• Amino Powder Cleanser 75%
• Kaolin clay 23%
• Vitamin B5 1%
• Papaya Enzyme 1%

Regarding the use of Kaolin clay, the staff mentioned that it might not be ideal for a powder cleanser as it could turn into a muddy texture when mixed with water. However, you are welcome to experiment with this combination.

Regarding your question about adding herbal powder to this formula: Similar to Kaolin clay, adding other powders like herbal powder might also affect the texture and consistency of the powder cleanser when wet.

Proposed Formula 2

• AminoWash 25%
• BabyFoam 50%
• Goat Milk Powder 22.5%
• Vitamin B5 1%
• Papaya Enzyme 1%
• Protease Enzyme 0.5%

The staff confirmed that this formula can be mixed.

Regarding Goat Milk Powder in this formula:

• The staff noted that while the formula is mixable, the high percentage (22.5%) of Goat Milk Powder makes the formula costly.
• They also pointed out that at this concentration, Goat Milk Powder won't provide significant skin benefits as it is washed off immediately.
• If the purpose is only for advertising claims, a much lower concentration (0.1-1.0%) is sufficient.
• You also mentioned the website suggests using a preservative with Goat Milk Powder, which is a valid consideration, especially with natural ingredients.
• While Goat Milk Powder might help with scent masking, the staff's point about the high cost and lack of skin benefit at this concentration remains relevant.

Hope this helps!