Formulation for Oily, Acne-Prone Skin: Evaluating Proposed Formulas
Question
Based on my previous sticky formula, I have developed two new formulas for my oily, acne-prone skin: one for acne treatment and one for nourishing. Is splitting the ingredients into these two formulas a better approach than my previous single formula?
- Formula 1 (Acne Treatment): Contains Azelaic Acid, BHA, and Vitamin C.
- Formula 2 (Nourishing Cream): Contains Hyaluronic standard (considering Nano Hyaluronic Acid), Vitamin E, and uses a cream base with Sepiplus 400.
Are these two proposed formulas suitable for my skin type, or should I consider a single, simpler formula as previously suggested?
Answer
You asked if splitting your ingredients into two formulas would be better and give better results compared to your previous single, overloaded formula.
Based on the staff's feedback on your two proposed formulas:
- Formula 1 (Acne-focused): The staff advised against using Azelaic Acid in this formula because you are already using BHA and Vitamin C. Combining these can lead to excessive skin irritation.
- Formula 2 (Nourishing Cream): The staff recommended changing Hyaluronic standard to Nano Hyaluronic Acid for potentially better skin penetration. More importantly, the staff repeatedly advised that an oil-based or cream base (like using Vitamin E and Sepiplus 400) is generally not recommended for your skin type (oily, acne-prone), suggesting a water-based gel texture would be more suitable.
While splitting ingredients into formulas targeting different concerns can be a good strategy, these specific formulas, as proposed, still contain elements that the staff has advised against for your skin condition and current routine (e.g., potential irritation from combining actives, unsuitable base for oily/acne-prone skin).
The staff's overall recommendation throughout the conversation has been to simplify your formula, use fewer ingredients, and avoid oils and cream bases, opting instead for a water-based gel texture which is more suitable for oily and acne-prone skin.
Therefore, based on the staff's feedback, these two specific formulas may not be significantly better or more suitable than your previous one, as they still include elements that are not ideal for your skin condition according to the advice provided.