Simple Retinal Body Formulation & Efficacy Comparison with Perfect-A

Asked by: bomnamidang On: May 18, 2022 Product Type: Cosmetics

Question

How can I make a simple body lotion or serum with Retinal-EZ™ without needing a blender, and which ingredient, Retinal or Perfect-A™ (Hydroxypinacolone Retinoate), has documented proof of stimulating collagen synthesis in humans? (Also noting Tretinoin is unavailable).

Answer

Simple Retinal Body Formulation and Efficacy Comparison

Here is a simple way to incorporate Retinal into a body formulation without needing a blender, and a comparison of Retinal and Perfect-A efficacy.

Simple Retinal Body Formulation (No Blender)

For a simple body lotion or serum using Retinal that doesn't require blending, you can use Retinal-EZ™ (Encapsulated Water Dispersible Retinal). This form of Retinal is encapsulated and dispersible in water, making it easy to mix directly into a pre-made lotion or cream base, or a simple water-based serum base.

Simple Method:

  1. Choose a suitable lotion or cream base.
  2. Weigh out the desired amount of base.
  3. Weigh out Retinal-EZ™ at a recommended usage rate (typically 1-5%, recommended 5%).
  4. Weigh out Safe-B3™ (Vitamin B3, Niacinamide), which is recommended to use with Retinal to help reduce potential irritation and enhance effectiveness.
  5. Add Retinal-EZ™ and Safe-B3™ to the base.
  6. Stir gently until fully dispersed. Avoid excessive heat during mixing.
  7. Package in an opaque container to protect from light.

This method avoids the need for heating or high-shear mixing (blending).

Retinal vs. Perfect-A™ (Hydroxypinacolone Retinoate) Efficacy

Both Retinal (Retinaldehyde) and Perfect-A™ (Hydroxypinacolone Retinoate) are forms of Vitamin A recognized for their anti-aging benefits, including the potential to improve skin structure and reduce wrinkles. Vitamin A is currently the only cosmetic ingredient medically accepted as effective in anti-aging.

Based on the information available, the general order of efficacy for Vitamin A forms (from highest to lowest conversion to the active form, Retinoic Acid) is:

  • Retinal (Retinaldehyde)
  • Hydroxypinacolone Retinoate (Perfect-A™)
  • Retinol

Retinal is considered more potent than Perfect-A™ because it requires only one conversion step in the skin to become Retinoic Acid, whereas Perfect-A™ is a retinoid ester that also converts to the active form.

While both are effective, Perfect-A™ offers advantages in terms of stability and typically causes less skin irritation compared to Retinal and Retinol.

The description for Retinal mentions experimental results showing improvements in skin structure markers (keratin, transglutaminase, involucrin, filaggrin) after using 0.5% Retinaldehyde for one month. These markers are related to skin barrier function and overall skin health, which contributes to a youthful appearance.

Regarding specific documentation on collagen synthesis in humans, the descriptions state that Vitamin A in general is medically recognized for anti-aging and wrinkle reduction. While these effects are often linked to collagen production, the provided descriptions do not contain specific comparative human clinical trial data explicitly measuring collagen synthesis for Retinal versus Perfect-A™. However, based on the conversion pathway and general efficacy ranking, Retinal is considered highly effective.

Regarding Tretinoin

You mentioned Tretinoin. Please note that Tretinoin is a prescription-only substance and is not available for cosmetic formulations.