Sunscreen SPF Calculation and Nano Particle Safety
Question
Regarding the sunscreen formula from your store that uses 5% TD and 5% Zinc, resulting in SPF 23:
- How is this SPF value calculated?
- If I increase the concentration by 1 or 2 times, will the SPF value increase proportionally by 1 or 2 times?
- I have read articles claiming that nano TD and Zinc can penetrate the skin. Is this true, and are they harmful to the body?
Answer
SPF Calculation and Nano Sunscreen Safety
Regarding the calculation of SPF 23 from a formula containing 5% Titanium Dioxide and 5% Zinc Oxide, SPF calculation is not a simple direct addition of the values from each ingredient. It depends on the specific type and concentration of each sunscreen agent, as well as other factors in the formulation. You can find basic calculation methods in the product details of each ingredient. For example, some types of Titanium Dioxide at 1% concentration yield an SPF of approximately 2.0.
If you increase the concentration of sunscreen ingredients by 1-2 times, the SPF value will increase, but it will not increase proportionally by 1-2 times the amount added. For instance, doubling the amount might increase the SPF by approximately 1.8 times, which is a non-linear relationship.
Regarding whether nano Titanium Dioxide and Zinc Oxide penetrate the skin and are harmful, this is currently a widely debated topic. Reliable research to date has not confirmed that these nano particles can actually penetrate the skin, as many very small particles in the air do not penetrate the skin. The belief that nano particles penetrate the skin therefore lacks clear research support. Generally, physical sunscreens (like Titanium Dioxide and Zinc Oxide) work by coating the skin surface to reflect or scatter UV radiation, and are thus considered safer than chemical sunscreens which may be absorbed into the skin.
Please don't worry about posting in the wrong forum section. We are happy to provide information.