Toner Formulation Issues: Foaming, Mattifying Agent, and Ingredient Compatibility

Asked by: sanook733 On: April 01, 2016 Product Type: Cosmetics

Question

I am making a toner formulation using the following ingredients:

  • Witch Hazel
  • Vitamin B6
  • TransWhite
  • Encapsulated Salicylic Acid (BHA, Timed-Release) 5%
  • MatteSilica
  • AcneBee

I have the following questions:

  1. Can this formula be made as listed?
  2. Can a mattifying agent like MatteSilica be included in this toner formulation?
  3. Why does the toner foam slightly when I use it to wipe my face?

Answer

Based on the conversation you provided, here are the answers to your questions:

  1. Can this formula be made?

    • The full formula you proposed cannot be made as is, because MatteSilica and AcneBee are not compatible with a water-based toner (MatteSilica is a powder and will settle, and AcneBee is not water-soluble).
    • However, the remaining ingredients (Witch Hazel, B6, TransWhite, Encapsulated Salicylic Acid) can be mixed.

  2. Can a mattifying agent be included?

    • The specific mattifying agent you mentioned, MatteSilica, cannot be included in a toner formula for the reasons mentioned above.
    • No alternative mattifying agent suitable for toners was suggested in the provided conversation.

  3. Why does the toner foam slightly when wiping the face?

    • The slight foaming is caused by the Encapsulated Salicylic Acid. According to the staff, if this product is used at a concentration exceeding 3% in a formula, it may cause small bubbles to form. Your formula uses 5%, which is why the foaming occurs. The bubbles are small and disappear quickly after contacting the skin.

Additional Note:

  • The staff also advised you to remember to add a preservative to the mixed toner formula.

Tags

Compatibility Foaming Formulation Feasibility Oil Control Water-based Formulation